In Aleem v E-Act Academy Trust Limited, the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) upheld an Employment Tribunal’s decision that it was not a reasonable adjustment to permanently protect a teacher’s pay who was no longer fit to teach because of her disability.
The Claimant (C) was a science teacher. Due to ill-health, she took significant periods of sickness absence and eventually returned to her role in the capacity of cover supervisor. During this period, C continued to be paid at the teacher’s rates while she was under probation in the new role and whilst a grievance was considered. Thereafter, C was offered the cover role at a reduced level of pay, which she accepted.
The Claimant argued that her employer had failed to make reasonable adjustments. The EAT had to consider the differing judgments of O’Hanlon, where it was held that maintaining pay was not a reasonable adjustment and G4S v Powell, where it was held that maintaining pay was a reasonable adjustment. The EAT explained that Powell had not set any general principle but that the ET in that case made a decision it was entitled to given the particular facts of that case, in particular that G4S had promised to protect pay indefinitely.
In Aleem, when considering whether the adjustment sought was reasonable, the EAT held that the tribunal was entitled to weigh the cost of the adjustment (long term pay protection) – in this case it was noted that it could have easily ran into a six-figure sum – against the employer’s financial position. It also noted that the Claimant was free to reject the offer and the terms but she chose to accept it and the contractual terms, including pay, with that role.
On 10 June 2022 the government set out new regulations providing that pharmacists and nurses (as well as other types of healthcare professional) will be given the power to issue sick notes to individuals in England and Wales, with the change in law to take effect from 1…
What is a settlement agreement? At Waterfront we advise on settlement agreements every week but for our employee clients, signing such an agreement can be a once-in-a-lifetime event. If you have been offered a settlement agreement for the first time and you are finding the process confusing or…
This month it was reported that Tesco has announced a partnership with office space provider IWG to trial a flexible working space in its New Malden store. The space will comprise 12 private desks, 30 co-working spaces and a meeting room. The idea is that it suits workers…
Since the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority started recording information in 1991, around 390,000 babies have been born via in vitro fertilisation (“IVF”) or donor insemination. Historically a taboo subject, it is (quite rightly) more acceptable than ever for couples to seek medical assistance with conceiving. However, employers…